Dance is a funny thing though, see, because since the development of the new system, dance has changed the most of any discipline. I actually LIKE dance a lot now (which could also be attributed to my age, because as a child I hated it) OR it could be because of the new system. Or a mix of both. Regardless, dance IS a much stronger discipline now because of the requirements (but that's just IMHO and there's a whole 'nother post on that another day). So I have a hard time comparing dances of old to dances of new.
But I'll give it a shot.
First - off the top of my head, contenders:
1. Shae-Lynn Bourne and Victor Kraatz - Canadian Ice Dance champs for a billion years and 2003 World Champions.
2. Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir - Olympic, World, and Canadian Dance champs - Canada.
3. Meryl Davis and Charlie White - Olympic and World Silver Medalists, US Dance champs - USA
4. Jayne Torvill and Christopher Dean - Olympic, World, European, and British Dance champs - Britain.
5. Tracy Wilson and Robert McCall - Canadian champs, World and Olympic Bronze Medalists - Canada
6. Isabelle Duchesnay and Paul Duchesnay - World Champions and Olympic Silver Medalists - France
7. Oksana Grishuk and Evgeny Platov - World, Olympic, and Nationals Champs - Russia
8. Marina Anissina and Gwendal Peizerat - World, Olympic, and National Champs - France (though did compete for Russia and won Jr Worlds - just in case you care).
I realize I seem to be a little heavy hitting on the Canadian teams (three in my top 8)...and am missing a whack load of Russians...but I just don't love the Russians. These are the teams that had programs pop into my head instantly. Without second thought. Tanith Belbin and Ben Agosto (US Champs and Olympic Silver medalists) DID pop into my head, and while she may be Canadian by birth, I just don't have any great memory of their programs. Oh and the Kerrs, but same reason. So.
The Top Five Dance Programs of All Time:
5. Shae-Lynn Bourne and Victor Kraatz - River Dance - 1998 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nduwt9lgSks - I STILL love this program - this is one of the few ice dance programs I enjoyed in my younger years. In a time without "rules" and much politicking, this program was creative, different, and ingenious. Seriously.
4. Marina Anissina and Gwendal Peizerat - I Have a Dream - 2002 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RyJknaDA7II&feature=related - They were the ones who came up with the woman lifting the man. And I'm a sucker for "I Have a Dream..."
3. Shae-Lynn Bourne and Victor Kraatz - Adagio in G Minor - 2003 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0c55JUbCtI - I included this program and will quote from the comments from YouTube, because it's brilliant: "What's really sad is to win this medal they had to do a program that was the antithesis of everything great about their skating." It's true - this is the year they won Worlds (while they deserved to a multitude of times prior) - this was really the only time they skated to something like this...and it was brilliant...and yet the irony is so thick you could butter your toast with it.
2. Jayne Torvill and Christopher Dean - Bolero - 1984 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2zbbN4OL98 - While I can appreciate that at the time, THIS was perfection, I can't grasp the choppiness of this program. I know - it's supposed to be that way. But it wasn't jaw-dropping to me - I wasn't blown away the first time I saw it (I know, I know) - BUT as I watch it over and over, I am impressed with the use of every beat of the music, the creativity, etc. Again, maybe in this day and age, they would do something jaw-dropping, something better than my number 1. I can't compare it next to my number 1, because it's something different. But for the time and the place and the age - it was unique, different, and special.
And the winners, clearly, without doubt in my mind...
Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir - Symphony No. 5 by Mahler - 2010 - Never before has a skating program (and that's saying something) touched me like this. I was SOBBING by the end of the dance and I didn't even "get" it - that's called interpretation - that's using the nuance in the music. That's performance. There was not an error. A bobble. Nothing. THIS is perfection.
(And I know...no Russians. I'm probably biased. But I can't help it).











